February 24, 2009
Chair
Educational Policy Studies
University of Alberta
7th Floor Education North
Edmonton, Alberta
T6G 2M7
Chair:
This letter is a followup to the matter of my unfinished program in Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta. This letter will be available as part of the documentation I will provide to officials where required. These officials may include case workers at Ontario Works, as well as officials representing federal and ministry governments.
I have succeeded in collating a satisfactory range of data from which to carry out the critical analysis I had proposed to the department when I was a student and paying tuition. The data is available in a collection entitled Fifty Essential Twentieth Century Canadian Public Education Commission Reports. I had made the collection available on the internet during the time I was working on it, and I attach a copy of the home-page as it looked on my website before it was blocked by Telus. The collection took two to three concentrated years of daily transcription to create its current size, with additional varied levels of transcription ongoing between the years 2006 and this letter. The website involved additional intensive work particularly for two upgrades of the documents, including ongoing upload to the Telus server directory of upgraded policy documents in entire form as well as by chapter. This collection is very large. In hard copy I have, with .25 cm margins the collection is more than 45 cm deep, one-sided only, 12 point in Times font. At this time all the transcribed documents exist on the hard-drive of my computer and are backed up on CD. The utility of the collection is that it provides a one-stop reference to Canadian public education commission reports of the 20th century providing possibilities for study and research. The collection is now currently designed for the internet, but I also envision it as a hard copy resource available in education libraries.
All the documents are regularized into an organized filing system as CanEdPolDocs with the year, province, and chapter designation following. For example, the website designation for Alberta's entire Cameron Report is CanEdPolDoc1959Alberta.html. I have brought together in one file, CanEdPolDocAlbertaAllReports.html, a series of important Alberta public education commission reports, including the Cameron and Worth Reports. Students studying the public education policy history of Alberta might find such a collection useful for their research or provincial history policy course. This collection, if made available for those studying education policy in the department, would offer access to Alberta's historical documents online, or perhaps on CD. I would be pleased, with reasonable compensation for my labour and for the idea, to make the collection available to University of Alberta's Educational Policy Studies for distribution.
Goulson's two little known source books(1) provided a guide to deciding what Canadian documents of the 20th century would be most important to include in the data set I was building for the purposes of analysis. I entered his documents, originally sorted by province, onto a spreadsheet and was then able to sort them chronologically and by type of commission report. This one and only chronological sorting of commission reports produced in Canada is also on the hard-drive of my computer. This list was also available on the website also. Last year I began building in links to Canadian public education electronic commissions and reports available from 1994. So, the collection now provides an acceptable range for analysis. A natural extension to studying Goulson's source book for the purposes of comparative research was completing the list from 1983 where Goulson left off up to the year 2000. This spin-off project is entitled, following Goulson's example, A source book of Royal Commissions and other major governmental inquiries in Canadian education 1984-2000. This in itself is a valid PhD research project, certainly when you consider the time it would take to search through the primary to tertiary documents for the time frame, and certainly with chronological sorting and academic explanation. I assert here that my data is valid as data as it utilizes the endorsed work of Cary F. Goulson whose primary work is published as an education library reference. The data allows us to scan the thinking of primary Canadian education experts contributing their ideas via royal commissions in the 20th century. The commissions are foundational to public education.
A secondary spin-off resulting from my chronological collation of the data provided by Goulson, is an ongoing project consolidating all the available public education policy documents in chronological order from 2001 to this year. The list of public education policy documents produced in the 20th century is missing 17 years of information. With the lack of attention to this type of research work, sorting is behind at this time by 26 years. Why is it that the department conveyed to me through the FGSR [Faculty of Graduate Studies & Research] representative that rather than doing the important work of sorting, classifying and transcribing, I was "just copying?" Not only do these statements suggest that my previous education was faulty, particularly the Master's from University of Western Ontario, but it suggests that all study that led up to the PhD level was substandard. Further what was also implied in my case, is that I earned my Master's using talents that were other than intellectual. I do believe that the professors who passed my Master's at Western would be greatly insulted. What I was subjected to was ignorance, sexism, and province/territories discrimination. What stopped me from studying as a Canadian isn't anything less than outright corruption of the essential values of the Canadian public university.
I have been on interest relief for the student loan since 2006. I cannot find a job due to switching to a national comparative. This was advised by Jerry Kachur, and the switch required much more time to finish. I now question this redirection and the motive behind it, as I was accepted to the department based on a written proposal required with the application. I cannot find a teaching job at the elementary or secondary level because this national comparative project caused too large a gap in my practice. I do not have any loan amounts to cover an upgrade in a teacher education program here in Ontario. I have used 540 of the 520 allotted to me. I can continue to receive amounts to complete the level of the PhD, however. I shouldn't have to go back to elementary or secondary teaching anyway. I set a career goal to work at the level of the university and I put in place everything required by the university to do that. I completed a written Master's and it met University of Western Ontario's requirement to make a contribution to the literature. This Master's is available through Amicus. (2) The thesis is specifically in the category of public education policy and is published because of the information that it offers. It was not a "soft" project as assumed by Jerry Kachur who did not read it until two years after I entered the program. He admitted his error in assessing my work to Gerry Taylor.
I was discriminated against as a talented woman. It was faculty culture that I must submit to "personal connection" in order to graduate. I followed through as required, and that was what the department secretly diminishes me on, but the root to the problem is gender discrimination. This is in contradiction with the stated policy of the university. Sexist values put me in the situation, and sexist values then judged against me as a legitimate academic. In the department, powerful women who could have made the difference were also extremely sexist against women like me. I was branded as a femme fatale out to ruin a male career, but I acted on the basis of observing many promotions facilitated internally on the basis of "sexual/spousal connection," not on the basis of merit. The assessment of my program was never merit-based, instead I was battling sexism, ignorance and the glass ceiling rather than reworking chapters and fixing footnotes.
Jerry Kachur was also going to war on the matter of credential inflation, specifically directing hostility to students he categorized as substandard. I say he made a personal, professional and intellectual error in judgement of the Master's I completed at University of Western Ontario, and the course papers that I wrote based off this original research. I entered with everything required, but in the end was denied an appropriate supervisor and thus the right to study as a Canadian.
I have no resources to pay creditors and I owe at least $10,000.00. I lost my son's education savings plan worth a minimum of $3000.00 in 2005 because I had no money in my account. My Ontario and Canada Student Loans are in interest relief since 2006. These are three of the negative consequences I experienced because of negligence in Educational Policy Studies. I have had to endure additional expense in moving in an amount that is at least $5000.00, and have had to replace furniture and items in Edmonton and Ontario while being denied references required to make a living in my profession. I had to exercise the second option dictated to me by Frank Peters using his colonial Irish accent, that I go to another university. What he meant was that the expense of my education would prevent me from continuing, I would have to endure the costs of moving or the costs of legal proceeding. Mr. Peters never had these extra costs associated with his PhD, and the petty tuition he paid will never be experienced again by students in the 21st century in Canadian universities. His position was a consequence of his lack of respect for me, his sexism, misogyny, and his Canadian public education policy ignorance. The other option given by Mr. Peters was that I go to FGSR. However, Jerry Varsava the representative there, was removed from my case June 2007 because he had, among other things, made a deliberate entry into my academic transcript intended to block my finishing. He did this on behalf of Educational Policy Studies.
My health and confidence have been integrally affected. I cannot afford new reading glasses or to go to the dentist. I have to go to the food bank because of the limitations in my budget. I am in subsidized housing as I do not have the resources for a unit that allows my son a separate bedroom. I have no car and no money for new clothing. I have no extra resources for my son to experience extra-curricular activities. I have had my life ruined as the ultimate consequence of Jerry Kachur's negligence.
I attach a copy of my transcript as well as the document that I provided to Lisa Dalla Costa, Ontario Works caseworker, outlining my debt to Ontario and the Government of Canada for my Masters completed at the University of Western Ontario, as well as the PhD in Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta. I attach a copy of our agreement since this letter represents the job search I am responsible to Ontario Works for. I explained to Ontario Case Worker Lisa Dalla Costa that I cannot look for work in my area of expertise, comparative Canadian public education policy of the 20th century, as I am blocked by hostile references and an unfinished program.
Based on what I have written in this letter outlining my progress and intentions, and based on my past academic attainment, I request that any discrediting of me through references cease immediately. I want to work at the level of the university and share my expertise with students. I believe my PhD work, particularly when the analysis is complete, will show that my work is excellent and in advance, just as it was with my Master's. I believe my research will open up national understanding in public education policy across Canada. My collection makes possible a survey course on 20th century Canadian public education policy. There is nothing in my academic or career background that says that I should be denied a PhD once a perfect doctoral dissertation is submitted.
An academic precedent was set in 1966 by Cary F. Goulson whose PhD involved constructing the source book now available in reference libraries. The collection I have been consolidating entitled Fifty Essential Twentieth Century Canadian Public Education Commission Reports provides such a range of possibilities in terms of research and comparative Canadian public education policy history, that it should be considered equivalent to a doctoral dissertation. This should certainly be the case with an introductory analysis and some comparative work to create groupings requiring explanation. It has been five years in the making.
However, I do understand that Educational Policy Studies requires women like me to do ten times the work of any man, therefore, I will be working this year on the analysis of the collection. The working title is Theorising 20th Century Canadian Public Education Policy. I am using a theory framework proposed in a SSHRC [Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council] application that was submitted and approved by Ali Abdi and considered for a grant circa 2002 by the SSHRC committee. This theoretical model was decided on under the influence and expertise of Jerry Kachur, and it is outlined by Clyde Barrow (1993) in his Marxist Theories of the State as the "systems analytic," defined mainly by the work of Jurgen Habermas.
Yours sincerely,
Jane D. King.
Attachments
1. Loan summary
2. Resume
3. Transcript
4. Ontario Works Contract, Dalla Costa
5. Website Home page copy
6. CanEdPolDoc chapter sample
1. In 1981 University of Toronto Press published "A source book of Royal Commissions and other major governmental inquiries in Canadian education, 1787-1978, authored by Cary F. Goulson. University of Victoria followed in 1985 with a "A source book of Royal Commissions and other major governmental inquiries in Canadian education 1979-1983.
2. http://www.nlc-bnc.ca/obj/s4/f2/dsk3/ftp05/mq30841.pdf

No comments:
Post a Comment