Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Letter to Dr. K, Educational Policy Studies, University of Alberta




Dr. K, Educational Policy Studies, University of Alberta:

   Last year I was able to find and read a final set of late 20th century documents required for a doctoral dissertation "Theorizing 20th Century Canadian Public Education Policy" (working title). I also was able to advance the manuscript for this work in the years up to 2012 since I had an overall view of all the documents of interest existing up until the middle 1980s. Most of the documents are made available in a collection entitled "Fifty Essential 20th Century Canadian Public Education Commission Reports."  Last year I completed the manuscript to a "rough draft" containing six out of seven chapters. 
   In this letter I remind you that I met the two requirements you set for me while I was taking your courses and being supervised by you. First of all, you told me, despite the fact that I was admitted into the department with a proposal and references, that if I did not "go national" I would not have a career at the level of the university. And secondly, you encouraged your students to study and apply "critical theory" since you specialize in sociology and it is your area of knowledge and expertise. You may be aware of these two aspects of my work. I reiterate to you that I met your requirements because I:

DIRECTED A DOCTORAL DISSERTATION TO A NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE; and

STUDIED CRITICAL THEORY EXTENSIVELY IN ORDER TO APPLY IT IN THE DOCTORAL DISSERTATION.

   I have been working on meeting these requirements since being forced to leave University of Alberta. I having working on the doctoral dissertation despite extensive set-backs in my personal life as a consequence of the inappropriate treatment I received in Educational Policy Studies. I was also set back by the problem of making available for the research (and future researchers) the Canadian public education commission reports which in their collation would provide the essential foundations to the "national" treatment you recommended. Collating them has taken at least ten years. The logic of the approach I have taken is explained in the dissertation. 
   To reiterate, the "data set" for the doctoral dissertation is the collection of commission reports constructed by commissioners working on behalf of public governments in Canada during the years of the 20th century. The theory applied against the data is systems analytic. When chapter seven and the conclusion are completed I will have met the requirements you set to me as thoroughly as can be done considering the challenges set to me by the department. I would like to earn my PhD before I die.
   Dr. K, I am attaching the cost of my PhD which is constantly outlined to me in numerous brown envelopes I have been receiving for years from HRDC [Human Resources & Skills Development Canada]. Dr. K, I am also attaching a copy of a Revenue Canada letter concerning this amount. 
   After being forced to leave the department in 2006 I worked for a year in a call centre to make enough money to repair my car and cover expenses so I could drive back to Ontario from Alberta. I returned to Ontario in the summer of 2007. After returning I had no money and no job and I was on Ontario Works (welfare). I have also been helped with other social supports. And this is all as a consequence of choosing to study at the University of Alberta. Basically I returned to Ontario in order to rely on the social safety net -- social services and other products of liberal democracy -- it seems I studied so I could become a burden to the Canadian "welfare state." I think you have a lot to do with that because you made a “mistake” and the university wishes to cover it up in order to protect you and its reputation. 
   I invested into my education, but I have not been able to pay any part of my student loan because I work part time driving a school bus. I have had very limited resources even to continue the research. For example, I did not have the resources to go to Toronto and get a copy of the 1924 Manitoba document that I would like to add to the collection at University of Toronto’s Robarts Library. I don't have a car. I don't have enough income to pay off my student loan because I do not have the career I was working toward and dreaming of -- the career that would cover paying back the student loan. I think you have a great of responsibility toward that outcome for me. Where is the career that Canada says one can work towards and have if one does the hard work and applies oneself?   
   I would like to you to know that I would prefer to be able to pay off my student loan. This is the seventh year following being forced to consolidate in 2006, and if I do not get my opportunity to apply my knowledge skills as an academic, I will have to declare bankruptcy on my student loan and another additional debt of about 10,000 that I have also not been able to pay. I want Canadians to understand that I was never irresponsible in my commitment to my studies and in borrowing the money for my studies. I want Canadians to know I have a product for them and that I always intended to pay off my student loan. I want Canadians to KNOW WHY I CANNOT PAY MY STUDENT LOAN. I will not be declaring bankruptcy without letting HRDC [Human Resources & Skills Development Canada] know what I experienced in the department at U of A because I applied to the department in good faith based on a Canadian liberal merit-based system. I completed a Master's thesis in order to advance to study at a PhD level. In 2001 it was clear my Master's thesis was, by Canadian standards, excellent, although professors such as yourself in Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta refused to admit that I was legitimately attending the Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta. You and your colleagues would not give me respect as an academic and graduate student. I had worked very hard on my Master's, but the attitude in Educational Policy Studies, University of Alberta was that University of Western Ontario signed off something substandard. With the success of my Master's I believe I had earned the right to study at the PhD level. I didn’t take it for granted, however, I worked diligently in the EPS program, as you well know. I was confident, I was proud, but I wasn't arrogant. You said I was “aggressive,” to diminish me, but I was only “competitive.” I was doing well, so to justify your prejudice in making me stand behind a man with a salary and researching in an area indirectly related to the purpose of the department, you said selecting students was a “crap shoot.” I was blocked to completing a PhD in the department and I was consistently criticized, treated as a second-rate student, and diminished not only by you but also by others. But you played a large part in putting that into place for me.
   I was forced to consolidate my student loan in 2006 but as soon as I was back in Ontario and as soon as I could focus I endeavoured to complete the doctoral dissertation in the four hours of time I had/have between my a.m. and p.m. bus route. The current written analysis may suffered somewhat as a consequence of having to stop and start with it since 2006. However, I will be subjecting the manuscript to ongoing rigorous editing. I should have been free to study as a Canadian in any province, but I found I was not free to study as an Ontarian in public education policy at the University of Alberta. I was harassed not only as a woman but also as a graduate student from Ontario.
   Just as a reminder as to what I was up against as a valid student, I was told by Dr.V in FGSR [Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research] that the problem of diverse documents in varying Canadian locations was not to be solved in part through the approach of transcription. He said that I was "just typing." I thought this criticism was both sexist and problematic. It implied that I advanced to the PhD level either by cheating or through some failure of assessment at the University of Western Ontario. Of course, it didn’t explain the success of my Master's or the references from Western and so on. I was subjected to damaging diminishment by FGSR , but I do believe I would not have been over at FGSR if you had read my Master's thesis (this was your professional responsibility) and understood where I was coming from intellectually and academically. You didn't familiarize yourself with that document and you didn’t respect that I had earned the right to study at the PhD level, and it has cost me loss of income, status, confidence, as well as many other things. It has cost me years of lost production in key years of my life that should have been highly productive and contributing. As a consequence of the "mistake" you made , your sexism, and FGSR's mishandling of the problem, my financial life as well as key years in which I could have been developing my intellectual life and knowledge and applying my talents were essentially STOLEN from me.
      I have yet to complete chapter seven and a conclusion. Chapter seven is the most difficult chapter since it is the chapter where I consider the results of applying the theory to the data. This is the chapter where I endeavour to "theorize" Canadian 20th century public education policy. This is a perfect PhD challenge where sophisticated theory is applied to a specialized data set. The doctoral dissertation represents the academic and intellectual challenge of the research and the final result of PhD study. I do believe that the tuition I paid to University of Alberta should certainly allow me reasonable direction and critique of chapter seven and conclusion of the dissertation. But I do also understand that as a consequence of being the student that I was, and perhaps still am, in the department’s estimation, a negative estimation, I may continue to be blocked to this particular application of the tuition fees -- that of appropriate guidance and feedback for the key chapter of the dissertation. Nevertheless, I will endeavour to complete the project and I will be letting relevant institutions that should have an interest in this matter of the student loan provided by the Province of Ontario and the Government of Canada know when it the dissertation is complete. 
   A public university has a responsibility to permit the work of its varied, diverse and talented students to be made available to "the public," essentially through the process of publication, and this should be the case regardless of blocks applied to the student by highly paid professors defined as existing in the student’s character and behaviour. I do understand that the department has subjected me to, and still may be subjecting me to ongoing character assassination in order to cover up "mistakes" particularly yours. I also further understand that as a consequence of what I consider ongoing harassment and bullying I may never work at the level of the university due to the cover-up and University of Alberta’s desire to silence me. 
   Regardless of the University of Alberta's prejudice against me, the "Canadian public" should not be denied my contribution and I should be allowed to benefit from the credit that is extended to me when an academic program is completed. I was very excited about entering into the University of Alberta and the criticism and nastiness I experienced as a student was very hurtful. It has taken me a lot of counselling and consistent purposeful steps toward healing to be able to get past the abuse I received as a PhD student. I perhaps would have completed the doctoral dissertation sooner, but I suffered from depression and became very inefficient in managing administrative matters as a consequence of the ongoing bullying and diminishment I received. I had to work slowly to recover my efficiency. It has taken me many years to heal from the abuse I experienced in Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta, but I have continued to work toward completion of the doctoral dissertation. It seems that I will never be free to get on with my life with your department operating negatively against me, but I say this is a continuation of fear tactics used against me to prevent the corruption in the department from coming to light and to protect the highly paid professors to their questionable behaviour and "benefits" as well as their private elite “club.”
   I am mature now and I do not know when I will die, it could be soon and it could be later, but when I die Canadians are not going to care whether the University of Alberta approved of my personality or character, what I looked like and that Dr. P and others "disliked" me and that this was a predominant deciding factor as to whether I should complete or not. But Canadians may care that the public system and the Canadian public (the public that pays taxes into public systems) and the system actually existing (not the department) behind my studies receives the outcome of the process -- the doctoral dissertation and the data set. I know Canadians will want to read my analysis and have access to the collection I have put together and they should have access through the "public university." That is what the public university is for. There is no treatment available like mine anywhere in Canada and my treatment should be made available. There are no other Canadian minds that have engaged with the Canadian public education commission reports as I have. There are no Canadian minds with the comparative understanding that I have. In this regard I say I remain a valid PhD student and at this point I should not be denied when my analysis is complete to seek employment at the level of the university with the knowledge that I have and with the access to it that I have put into place. “The public" lent me the money to pay the tuition required by the University of Alberta so I could study and produce a product. 
   I believe in my work. I believe it is contributory to understanding and is important.  University of Alberta never hesitated to take the tuition fee for the program before I was permitted to access the remainder allotted for living expenses. If I have completed the object of the endeavour of a PhD then the Canadian public should not be denied access to it as a consequence of University of Alberta’s political stance against me. The department would say my case isn’t political. In my case and based on the discrimination and ugly treatment I received in the department, I would say that if Canadians are denied access to my work through the university such denial would amount to CENSORSHIP since a great deal of my negative experience as an Ontario graduate student working on public education policy in Alberta was POLITICAL. 
   Although a blog is not the best instrument for representing a doctoral dissertation, I have put the chapters I have worked on so far on a blog at www.canadianeducationalpolicystudies.blogspot.ca. This way I can take my problem of how Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta handled my program to the various entities that may be able to help me. The data set is available at www.canadianeducationalpolicystudies.ca.
   I also have enclosed copies of my tax assessments that will prove that I never entered into the arena of having SES [Social Economic Status] a status that you indicated that I should not be entitled to attain since my father was educated and middle class. I have not been able to access the middle class which is why I cannot pay off my student loan. The tax assessments will also show that I have not been able to collect a credit of 27,000 that would be applied to me if my income was reflecting my education and credentials.
   My my financial life has been ruined. My personal life has been ruined. My relationship with my son has been ruined as he has no respect for me since I am underemployed. He has also suffered from the years of poverty we have had to endure as a consequence of my choosing to study for a PhD. My ex's life was ruined since I studied in order to be able to make a living that would support me and my son in dignity. Instead my ex who has two other children is paying more than he can manage. Through all my years of study I sacrificed in order to complete a credential. My goal was to reach a point where I would be writing and thinking in an area of expertise. As a consequence of your negligence and sexism this goal has been denied to me. I have been robbed of my life's purpose.  I have considered suicide, but my son needs me and I am also determined that before I end my life I should make sure the doctoral dissertation is finished so my son may know what I had wanted to do with my education. He should know that I was always capable and able to finish. Even though he believes in the Canadian system and the goodness of people, he doesn't yet understand, that as a consequence of choosing Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta, I was cheated and reduced to zero and left with a huge student loan.  I was punished by the department for being who I am, for travelling to Alberta from central Canada, for being a single mom and a blonde woman, for being talented enough to work at the PhD level. Because of your negligence and sexism and how it negatively affected my studies and completion, I cannot pay the Province of Ontario and the Government of Canada. I have been robbed of my purpose in living by Educational Policy Studies at the University of Alberta.
   I believe my research can offer new understanding regarding the historical products and process of Canadian public education policy making in the 20th century as well as providing knowledge regarding how the commission reports of the 20th century relate and compare. If you learn anything new in reading my manuscript, don’t assume that it is “already out there,” as you did with my Master’s, and don’t forget to acknowledge the source to your new knowledge and understanding.

Yours sincerely,





















No comments:

Post a Comment